Good Schools Guide
  • Compare Schools
  • Open Days
  • Start Here
  • Insights
  • eBook
  • Login
  • Compare schools
  1. Home
  2. Insights
  3. Education updates
  4. Time to re-examine exams?

Time to re-examine exams?

Every year, tens of thousands of Victorian teenagers sit down for their VCE exams. They are told that their entire life will be shaped in the next fortnight and the value of 13 years of schooling will be assessed in a couple of essays, some multiple-choice questions and a handful of sums.

Surely there is a better way? After all, Einstein failed a few school exams in his time, as did Sir Winston Churchill, Bill Gates and Charles Darwin. Stephen Spielberg famously took three goes to get into film school, while Sir Isaac Newton never graduated from Cambridge. In fact, history is littered with high achievers who scored low marks in their exams.

Exams reward memory over understanding, and conformity rather than creativity. Are there “failures” with equal potential that we never hear from again? Yes, says prominent British educator Peter Tait. Whether it’s because they’re bored by conventional learning, think differently or only have certain, specialised interests, “many intelligent people” have found themselves “disfranchised” by exams.

Some commentators also argue that exams mean educators “teach to the test”, without exploring a subject beyond what is needed for the two hours of the exam. “For many, teaching has become dull, narrow and uninspiring,” writes Mehdi Hasan in The Guardian. “There is no reward for creativity, only results, results, results.”

On the flip-side, exams have the virtue of providing a standardised test at a standardised time, in standardised conditions. Their strength lies in their scalability and ability to assess large numbers of students at once, in locations around Victoria. They provide every student with a single score, which allows them to be ranked in each subject area.

However, this is only useful if the education system is considered an arena for students to complete against each other. Perhaps the exams themselves aren’t at fault, rather the system in which they exist. If the aim of education is to create people who possess knowledge they can apply and express, then surely there is no need to inflict students with the stress and anxiety of regurgitating everything they’ve attempted to remember?

Exams remain the assessment of choice for most courses and providers, due in part to the lack of genuine alternatives. Coursework is considered a key component to most qualifications, but there is too much potential for plagiarism or cheating for it to be the sole measure of success. Exams permit a student to be tested in a vacuum, without the potential for intrusion by outside factors. No phones, no internet access and no books allows each student to be pitted against the test paper without interference.

The question of whether exams are the best form of testing a student’s intelligence may not have a straight answer for the time being but it is a question that nevertheless should be asked.

exams Year 12
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

A parent guide to university offers


13 Jan 2014

read more

A parent's guide to Year 12 exams


13 Nov 2017

read more

A student's guide to handling stress and staying focused at school


17 Sep 2020

read more

Popular schools
Academy of Mary Immaculate
Academy of Mary Immaculate
Aitken College
Aitken College
Alphington Grammar School
Alphington Grammar School
Arden Anglican School
Arden Anglican School
Australian Christian College - Darling Downs
Australian Christian College - Darling Downs
Australian Christian College - Moreton
Australian Christian College - Moreton
Browse more schools
Content Sections
  • Choosing a high school 15
  • Financing your child's education 4
  • At school and beyond 12

Join the conversation

Browse Schools

  • Schools in Canberra/ACT
  • Schools in Sydney/NSW
  • Schools in Brisbane/QLD
  • Schools in Adelaide/SA
  • Schools in Hobart/TAS
  • Schools in Melbourne/VIC
  • Schools in Perth/WA
  • Schools in Darwin/NT

Open Day Dates

  • Open Days in Canberra/ACT
  • Open Days in Sydney/NSW
  • Open Days in Brisbane/QLD
  • Open Days in Adelaide/SA
  • Open Days in Hobart/TAS
  • Open Days in Melbourne/VIC
  • Open Days in Perth/WA
  • Open Days in Darwin/NT

Browse Term Dates

  • Term Dates in Canberra/ACT
  • Term Dates in Sydney/NSW
  • Term Dates in Brisbane/QLD
  • Term Dates in Adelaide/SA
  • Term Dates in Hobart/TAS
  • Term Dates in Melbourne/VIC
  • Term Dates in Perth/WA
  • Term Dates in Darwin/NT
© 2025 Good Schools Guide
About us | About our data | Terms and conditions | Privacy policy
Good Education GroupAbout | Contact | Bookshop
Good Universities GuideGood Schools GuideStudies in AustraliaACIR